| Platinum | Arianna's Bake Shoppe |
| Gold | Michie's Custom Creations |
| Silver | La Rose Italian Bakery |
| Bronze | Hillary's Cupcakes & Desserts |
| Top Pick | Delicious Cakes By Christina |
| Top Pick | Haidys Cookies |
| Top Pick | Mmm cookies |
| Top Pick | Monastery Bakery & Delicatessen |
| Top Pick | Sweeter By The Dozen |
| Top Pick | Voortman Cookies |